The paper analyzes the possibility and usefulness of employing Augmented Reality (AR) in the manufacturing sub-processes of a complex machine produced in a small number, such as for custom turnkey plants for sorting and packaging vegetables or fruits or for automated lines for assembling electromechanical components.
This will be followed by a second article devoted to the application of AR in field activities, with a focus on installation and testing at the customer’s plant.
Augmented Reality (AR) is a technology that superimposes digital content (text, images, 3D models, animations) on the real world, enriching the perception of the physical environment without replacing it. The latest generation devices offer advanced AR experiences: the user, wearing a transparent visor, continues to see his or her surroundings while interacting with digital objects projected into his or her field of view, including through voice, gesture and eye commands.
Unlike Virtual Reality (VR), which immerses the user in a completely digital environment that is isolated from the real world, Augmented Reality (AR) superimposes digital content on top of the physical context, maintaining a direct link to the surrounding environment. This feature makes AR particularly effective in operational contexts, such as industrial maintenance or technical assistance in the field. In contrast, for training environments that require high immersion, repeatability of actions, and simulation of hazardous or abstract environments, VR proves more suitable, offering a more immersive, controlled, and safe experience.
Technologies used in AR include transparent optical viewers (allow the user to see both the real environment and overlaid digital objects-holograms), depth sensors (detect how far away objects are in the real world, creating a “3D map” of the environment) environmental cameras (capture what the user sees around him or her), advanced graphics processors (quickly process images and 3D models), eye-tracking (technology that detects where the user is looking), and spatial recognition algorithms (software that processes sensor and camera data). These components enable the system, among other things, to stably anchor digital objects to the physical environment. To effectively apply AR in different industrial contexts, it is essential to have custom applications, such as those developed by Widecons®, tailored to meet the specific needs of each plant or process.
In addition, AR offers comprehensive, contextual and real-time operational instructions that:
- They increase security;
- Reduce the risk of incorrect maneuvers;
- favor the introduction of novelties;
- accelerate the experience curve;
- Decrease defects;
- make it easier for new operators to perform complex operations.
Costs for AR adoption vary: a professional visor is priced at a few thousand euros, to which software development and integration costs must be added. However, the benefits in terms of operational efficiency, safety, quality and error reduction amply justify the investment even in the short term.
The case study
The ETO (Engineer-To-Order) process for a turnkey line for sorting and packaging vegetables or fruits is typical of the agribusiness sector, where each project is highly customized according to the type of product (carrots, tomatoes, apples, etc.), production capacity, and the needs of the end customer (e.g., layout, plant engineering).
The main steps of the ETO process are:
Order acquisition
The customer’s request with technical specifications, types of products to be processed (whole or cut fruits/vegetables), automation requirements, space constraints and regulations (e.g., HACCP) is transformed into a technical/commercial bid document (preliminary layout, flows, costs, time).
Machine development
Based on the specifications defined in the bidding phase, customer order and technical constraints, mechanical working drawings, wiring diagrams, PLC/HMI software, bill of materials are produced.
Manufacture
At this stage, starting with bills of materials and construction drawings, components and assembled modules are purchased and produced, ready for testing.
Specifically, once the machine design is completed, technical documentation is prepared, which usually includes the BOM, bill of materials, assembly drawings, construction drawings, and technical specifications. This documentation is analyzed to assess the level of saturation of internal production capacity. Based on this assessment, a decision is made on which components to make in-house (make) and which to outsource (buy).
- For the make part, production orders are issued for internal carpentry, accompanied by the relevant technical specifications and construction drawings. Once completed, the internal carpentry is made available for the machine assembly stages.
- For the buy part, purchase orders are issued for external carpentry, attaching the same technical documentation. The supplier makes the delivery accompanied by the Bills of Lading and Transportation Document (DDT). This is followed by the operations of receiving the material, checking compliance and handling any non-conformities
Assembly and final testing
When all components are available, the MRP (Material Requirements Planning) is launched, the material picking list is generated, the materials are prepared, and finally the machine is assembled.
Inbound testing is conducted for purchased parts, and special testing and simulations on the assembled line, to arrive at the line ready for shipment.
Installation and startup
Through a series of complex activities (installations, connections, calibrations, testing, staff training, final validation) the line, transported and assembled at the customer’s site, becomes an operational and validated plant. The final stage involves mechanical and functional testing. Based on the outcome of the testing, a review is made of any errors found. If necessary, we return to the machine development phase to make appropriate corrections.
Technical Assistance
Technical service includes scheduled preventive maintenance interventions and on-call activities in case of failures or anomalies.
Analysis of the application of AR to the fabrication of complex machine carpentry
Four of the stages described above are analyzed below.
1 – Machine development. In this initial and crucial stage of the process, key technical documentation is produced and analyzed: bill of materials, bill of materials, construction and assembly drawings, and technical specifications.
The introduction of Augmented Reality (AR) makes a strategic contribution at this stage:
- In fact, it allows three-dimensional (3D) visualization of the bill of materials
- The virtual verification of the machine layout in the operational context
- The sharing of templates for remote collaborative reviews.
These activities preemptively identify design errors, correctly measure overall dimensions, and increase the efficiency of engineering decisions.
Therefore, the application of AR in machine development has a high priority, as it directly impacts the quality of the entire production cycle and significantly reduces the risk of costly changes at later stages.
2 – The stage Make, within the manufacturing process of a complex machine, covers all activities of internal production of the carpentry. After deciding which parts to produce in-house, production orders accompanied by technical specifications and construction drawings are issued. This is followed by the actual fabrication of the parts, with special attention to the activities of welding and assembly.
The use of Augmented Reality (AR) at this stage provides operators with augmented visual instructions, superimposed in real time on the physical object. This approach allows for a immediate visual verification Of the correctness of processing, step by step. The main advantages are:
- Dramatic reduction of human errors, thanks to clear and interactive visual guides;
- Greater precision in operations, with higher and more uniform build quality.
For these very reasons, the application of AR in the Make has a very high priority, concretely increasing the production efficiency and quality of the final product.
3 – The stage Buy refers to the external sourcing of carpentry or other components needed to manufacture the machine. When, based on the saturation of internal resources, the decision is made to outsource to external suppliers production of certain parts, specific purchase orders accompanied by technical documentation (construction drawings and specifications) are issued. Once the materials are received from the supplier, the compliance verification assumes a key role.
This is where theAR can provide significant support, through:
- Increased quality checks, with visual overlay of tolerances and specifications to the actual part;
- Intelligent tracking of components., useful for logistics and document management;
- Simplified management of nonconformities., with visual and automatic reporting of deviations.
The use of AR at this stage allows for a faster and more accurate verification of incoming materials, also improving the traceability and consistency between what is ordered and what is actually delivered.
For these reasons, the priority of AR application at this stage is medium: it is a valuable opportunity, especially in high-volume or critical supply settings, but less strategic than other phases such as design or in-house production.
4 – The phase of assembly and final testing represents the culmination of the production process, where all components-internal or external-are assembled to bring the finished machine to life. At this stage the AR offers a very high value-added contribution, particularly on three levels:
- Guidance on picking of materials through augmented visual systems that indicate in real time what to pick, in what amount, and from where, reducing the risk of errors or omissions.
- Assisted assembly, through digital overlays that guide the operator step by step during assembly, ensuring accuracy and correct order of operations.
- Augmented testing thanks to interactive checklists viewable in AR, enabling systematic, tracked verification of machine functionality, with the ability to record, share and document outcomes in real time.
The main benefits of using AR at this stage include:
- Complete traceability of the operations carried out;
- Significant reduction in errors, even by less experienced operators;
- Immediate sharing of results of testing with other departments or customers.
Because of its crucial importance in ensuring the final quality of the product and the overall efficiency of the process, the assembly and testing stage is considered to be a high priority for the adoption of Augmented Reality.
Coming to the end of the analysis, we summarize the main information to have a clear picture that enhances the improvement path brought about by the introduction of AR.
Table of sintended
Phase | Where AR applies | Key benefits | Quantitative measures | Application priority |
1. Machine development | 3D BOM visualization, virtual layout verification, collaborative reviews | Reduction of design errors, prior verification of overall dimensions | Up to -30% design errors +25% layout review speed | High |
2. Make (in-house production) | Augmented welding and assembly instructions, real-time visual verification | Fewer human errors, increased speed and accuracy, reduced exposure to operational risks | -40% operational errors +20% productivity on manual operations | Very High |
3. Buy (external supplies) | Augmented quality control, component tracking, nonconformity management | Quick and accurate verification of materials, improved traceability | -25% inspection time +35% efficiency in NC management | Media |
4. Assembly and final testing | Guide to sampling, assisted assembly, augmented testing with interactive checklists | Full traceability, error reduction, real-time results sharing, visual support for safe maneuvering | -30% errors in testing +40% efficiency in checklist management | High |
Final considerations
The analysis conducted shows that, with different priorities, AR technology enables significant improvements in operational efficiency, quality and traceability along all stages of the production process, from design to testing. In addition, operator safety is increased.
In particular, the Make (in-house production) phase takes a very high priority, as it represents the point where the potential for recovery in terms of time, cost, and quality is greatest: AR significantly reduces operational errors, optimizes manual operation execution time, and improves accuracy, with direct effects on productivity and final product quality.
Below is a table with the estimated monthly recovery, generated by AR in the “Make” phase, on a production line with average data equal to: single shift of 8 hours/day, 10 operators, 22 days month, average hourly cost 40€
Table – Estimated recovery with use of AR at the “Make” stage.
Scope | Indicator | Estimated recovery value | Notes |
Quality | Defect reduction | -40% operational errors | AR applications in assembly and welding |
Time | Hours saved per month | +352 hours/month | +20% productivity (less operational time and less rework) on 10 operators (8h × 22gg) |
Costs | Monthly savings | ~14.080 € | 352 hours/month × 40 €/hour |
Annual economic savings: 168,960 €/year (14,080 € × 12)
Table – Estimated costs of AR implementation in the “Make” phase.
Cost item | Quantity | Unit cost (€) | Total cost (€) |
Next-generation AR viewers | 5 devices (shared use among the 10 operators) | 4.500 € | 22.500 € |
Widecons® custom AR app development for manufacturing | Dedicated app with visual instructions, checklists, easy integration with existing system | – | 25.000 € – 40.000 € |
Software licenses and services | 5 users with AR support | 1,000 €/year per user | 5,000/year |
Process consulting, operator training and initial setup from Widecons® | 8 days | – | 12.000 € |
Technical support and annual maintenance from Widecons® | Support + app updates | – | 3,000 €/year |
Total initial investment (one-time): ≈ €59,500 – €74,500
Annual recurring costs (licenses + support): ≈ €8,000/year
Return on investment (ROI): with estimated savings of €168,960/year, break-even is reached in about 4-5 months.
Scalability: the solution is scalable; by increasing the number of operators or expanding the functions of the app, the cost per user decreases.
Extra: If the app also includes voice functions, eye tracking or IoT integration, the development cost can rise to 60-80,000 €.
Conclusions
The case study analyzed clearly and measurably demonstrates that the adoption of the latest generation of AR devices, integrated with customized solutions, is a strategic lever for the digital transformation of production processes in ETO.
Specifically, in the Make phase, the use of augmented instructions, real-time visual checks, and interactive checklists generates an estimated annual recovery of more than 4.000 labor hours, resulting in economic savings of more than 165,000 euros per year, on a team of 10 operators.
For a small and widely scalable investment, the benefits obtained are objective, concrete and repeatable:
- Significant reduction in operational errors
- Increased efficiency and precision in manual operations
- Advanced traceability and risk reduction
These results are real data highlighting that AR-applied with state-of-the-art visors-is no longer a futuristic option, but a ready and recommended technology for improving productivity and competitiveness.
The next article will explore how AR can simplify and enhance the installation and testing of complex machines directly on-site.
Those who choose AR today build tomorrow’s competitive advantage.
The authors
Gaetano Rizzitelli
With more than 30 years of experience in the field, Gaetano Rizzitelli supports businesses and teams to grow competitively, sustainably and efficiently. He founded Blitz Kaizen and the innovative startup Widecons® to accompany SMEs on concrete paths of lean, digital and green transformation. He combines proven methodologies and emerging technologies to bring measurable, tailored results to Italian SMEs. It collaborates with manufacturing companies, startups and service realities to innovate processes and business models. He believes in the value of people and the potential of the organization as a harmonious system. His goal? To transform visions into concrete results.
Paul Berti
Temporary Manager with 25 years of management experience in Operations and Supply chain, gained in companies operating on a contract basis in the industrial sector, manufacturers of machinery, plants, automation, mainly in medium-sized multinational contexts. He has promoted and implemented tools for Lean Manufacturing, planning of activities involved in production processes, industrial cost control, budgeting, management and team involvement. His goal: to help companies improve and consolidate performance in Operations.